This week I bring you my own recipe for spicy peanut butter cookies. Peanut butter cookies are some of my favorite kind of cookie. These were inspired a few years back by finding a spicy peanut butter in a grocery store. It was “The Heat Is On” peanut butter from Peanut Butter & Co. They make some other great peanut butter flavors that can also be substituted in this recipe. This particular spicy peanut butter add heat with chili powder, cayenne peppers, crushed red peppers, and paprika. The resulting peanut butter cookie isn’t overly spicy, but has a nice flavor and a slow burn that hits you over time. The spicy peanut butter can sometimes be found in normal grocery stores or Whole Foods. If you can’t find any, the company does ship it on their website.
Here’s the recipe (makes about 3-4 dozen cookies):
1/2 cup granulated sugar
1 & 1/2 cup brown sugar
1 cup spicy peanut butter (The Heat Is On)
1 cup softened butter
2 large eggs
2 & 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
1 & 1/2 teaspoons baking soda
1 teaspoon baking powder
1/2 teaspoon salt
Some extra granulated sugar
Here is the mise en place for the cookies.
Like most cookies, these start with creaming the butter with the sugar. In this cake, it also includes the peanut butter. Some peanut butter cookie recipes call for adding the peanut butter after the dry ingredients have been added, I’ve found it easier to do at the beginning. Mixing at the end tends to cause you to over mix the flour and you end up with tough cookies.
Here are the two eggs about to go into the cookie dough.
Here is the cookie dough after adding the eggs.
This is the final cookie dough after the dry ingredients have been mixed in. It should still be pretty sticky, but firm enough to shape into balls and hold its shape.
The dough then gets rolled into balls about 1 & 1/2 inches in diameter and placed onto a baking sheet. I always prefer using a silpat covered air bake cookie sheet when baking cookies.
Then dip a fork into the extra sugar and press down each cookie twice. Once in one direction, the second time in the opposite direction. You’ll want to dip the fork into the sugar between each press so that it doesn’t stick to the cookie. If you are making different flavors of peanut butter cookies, you can experiment with different utensils and creating a different pattern on top each flavor of cookie. That way you can tell which flavor is which.
Here are the cookies after baking for about 11 minutes. There is one missing because my wife couldn’t wait until I took the picture to eat one.
And of course, here is a close up of one of the cookies.